Overview
A lease modification under ASC 842 is a change to the terms and conditions of a contract that changes the scope of a lease or the consideration for it. Exercising an option that was already in the contract is not a modification. It is a remeasurement event.
The accounting follows three steps:
- Is the modification a separate contract? If so, account for the new right of use as a new lease and leave the original lease unchanged.
- If not, reassess the classification of the modified lease at the effective date of the modification.
- Remeasure, using inputs and a discount rate updated to the effective date. Lessees adjust the right-of-use asset; lessors follow rules that depend on how the classification changed.
The effective date of the modification is the date the modification is approved by both the lessee and the lessor, which may differ from the date the change takes effect.
This article forms part of our ASC 842 series. See also operating leases for lessees.
Is the Modification a Separate Contract?
A modification is a separate contract when both of the following apply (ASC 842-10-25-8):
- It grants the lessee an additional right of use not included in the original lease, such as another floor or another vehicle.
- The lease payments increase commensurate with the standalone price of that additional right of use, adjusted for the circumstances of the contract.
The same test applies to lessees and lessors. A longer term for the same asset is not an additional right of use, so an extension is never a separate contract. Nor is a modification that adds space at a discount that does not reflect the circumstances of the contract.
Lessee Accounting
For a modification that is not a separate contract, the lessee, at the effective date:
- Reassesses lease classification using the modified terms and facts at that date.
- Reallocates the remaining consideration between lease and non-lease components.
- Remeasures the lease liability using the revised payments, the revised lease term and a discount rate determined at the effective date.
The right-of-use asset then depends on what the modification does:
| Modification | Right-of-use asset | Profit or loss |
|---|---|---|
| Adds a right of use (not a separate contract) | Adjusted by the change in the liability | None |
| Extends or reduces the term (other than through an existing option) | Adjusted by the change in the liability | None |
| Changes the consideration only | Adjusted by the change in the liability | None |
| Fully or partially terminates the lease (for example, surrendering part of the space) | Reduced in proportion to the part terminated | Gain or loss for the difference from the liability reduction |
The discount rate
The rate is the rate implicit in the lease if readily determinable, otherwise the lessee's incremental borrowing rate at the effective date, for the remaining term. Entities other than public business entities may use a risk-free rate for the remaining term if they elected that policy.
After the modification
- Operating lease: the remaining single lease cost equals the remaining payments of the modified lease, adjusted for prepaid or accrued rent, unamortised initial direct costs and unamortised incentives. It is recognised on a straight-line basis over the remaining term.
- Finance lease: interest on the liability and amortisation of the right-of-use asset continue from the remeasured amounts.
Where the classification changes, the lease is accounted for under the new classification from the effective date. See finance vs operating leases for lessees.
Lessee Example: Extending an Operating Lease
A lessee has a five-year operating lease of retail space at 100,000 per year, paid in arrears, with a discount rate of 5%. The lease has no extension option.
At the end of year 2, after the payment, the lease liability and the right-of-use asset are both 272,325 (three payments at 5%). The payments are level, so there is no accrued rent.
The lessee and lessor then agree to extend the lease by three years at 110,000 per year. The extension adds no new asset, so it is not a separate contract. The lease remains an operating lease. The incremental borrowing rate at the effective date is 7%.
- Remeasured liability: three payments of 100,000 and three of 110,000 at 7% = 498,076
- Increase: 498,076 − 272,325 = 225,751, debited to the right-of-use asset
- Remaining payments: 300,000 + 330,000 = 630,000
- Straight-line lease cost: 630,000 ÷ 6 = 105,000 per year
| Year after modification | Accretion (7%) | Payment | Lease liability | ROU reduction | ROU asset |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 34,865 | 100,000 | 432,942 | 70,135 | 427,942 |
| 2 | 30,306 | 100,000 | 363,247 | 74,694 | 353,247 |
| 3 | 25,427 | 100,000 | 288,675 | 79,573 | 273,675 |
| 4 | 20,207 | 110,000 | 198,882 | 84,793 | 188,882 |
| 5 | 13,922 | 110,000 | 102,804 | 91,078 | 97,804 |
| 6 | 7,196 | 110,000 | — | 97,804 | — |
The right-of-use asset reduction is the balancing figure: the straight-line cost of 105,000 less the accretion on the liability. The asset sits below the liability during the term by the accrued rent, which builds up to 15,000 by year 3 and reverses as the higher payments are made.
Lessor Accounting
A lessor applies the same separate contract test. For a modification that is not a separate contract, the lessor reassesses classification at the effective date, and the accounting depends on how the classification changes, assuming the modified contract is still a lease:
| Classification change | Accounting |
|---|---|
| Operating to operating | Treat as a termination of the existing lease and a new lease from the effective date. Prepaid or accrued rentals under the original lease are included in the lease payments of the modified lease. |
| Operating to sales-type | Terminate and recognise a new lease. Derecognise the underlying asset and any deferred or accrued rent, which adjust the selling profit or loss, and recognise a net investment. Selling profit or loss is recognised at the effective date. |
| Operating to direct financing | As for sales-type, except that only a selling loss is recognised at the effective date. Any selling profit is deferred and included in the net investment. |
| Direct financing to direct financing; sales-type to sales-type or direct financing | Adjust the discount rate so that the initial net investment in the modified lease equals the carrying amount of the original net investment immediately before the effective date. |
| Direct financing to sales-type | Apply sales-type accounting, with the effective date as the commencement date. Selling profit or loss is the fair value of the underlying asset less the carrying amount of the original net investment immediately before the effective date. |
| Direct financing or sales-type to operating | Recognise the underlying asset at the carrying amount of the original net investment immediately before the effective date, then apply operating lease accounting. |
ASC 842-10-55 illustrates these cases in Examples 20 to 22. For the underlying models, see sales-type leases and direct financing leases.
Why the discount rate is solved for
For a financing lease that stays a financing lease, the lessor does not remeasure the net investment at a market rate. It solves for the rate that makes the modified lease's net investment equal to its existing carrying amount, so no gain or loss arises and the change is spread over the remaining term through finance income.
Lessor Example: Operating Lease Extension
A lessor leases equipment for six years under an operating lease, with rentals of 50,000 per year in years 1 to 3 and 62,000 per year in years 4 to 6. Total rentals are 336,000, so straight-line income is 56,000 per year.
At the end of year 2, the lessor has recognised income of 112,000 and received 100,000, so it holds an accrued rent receivable of 12,000. The parties agree to extend the lease by two years at 65,000 per year. The lease remains an operating lease.
The modification is treated as a new lease from the effective date, with the accrued rent included in its lease payments:
- Remaining rentals: 50,000 + (3 × 62,000) + (2 × 65,000) = 366,000
- Less accrued rent receivable already recognised as income: (12,000)
- Income to recognise: 354,000 over six years = 59,000 per year
A prepaid rent liability would have the opposite effect, increasing the income recognised over the remaining term.
ASC 842 vs IFRS 16
| ASC 842 | IFRS 16 | |
|---|---|---|
| Separate contract test | Additional right of use at a commensurate standalone price | Same |
| Lessee: shorter term with the asset kept until the new end date | Remeasure against the right-of-use asset, no gain or loss | Decrease in scope: partial termination with a gain or loss |
| Lessee: discount rate | Updated at the effective date (risk-free rate option for non-public entities) | Revised at the effective date |
| Lessee: classification | Reassessed (operating or finance) | Single lessee model, no classification |
| Lessor: finance lease that remains a finance lease | Rate adjusted so the net investment is unchanged | IFRS 9 modification rules applied to the net investment |
For IFRS 16, see lease modifications under IFRS 16 and lease liability remeasurement. The wider comparison is in ASC 842 vs IFRS 16.
Recalculating modified leases in Excel?
Leash automates lease schedules, journal entries, and ASC 842 compliance, so you're not rebuilding this in Excel every month-end.
Conclusion
Under ASC 842, a lease modification is first tested as a separate contract. If it is not one, the lessee reassesses classification and remeasures the lease liability at an updated discount rate, adjusting the right-of-use asset, with a gain or loss only where part or all of the right of use ends. Lessors reassess classification and account for the modification according to how it changed: a new lease for an operating lease that stays operating, a solved-for discount rate for a financing lease that stays financing, and specific rules for each change between the two.
For clarification, guidance, or feedback on our article, please reach out to us at insight@leash.co.za.
