Overview
VAT on a lease in South Africa depends on how the lease is classified under the VAT Act, not on its IFRS 16 classification:
- Rental agreement: VAT is charged on each payment as it falls due. The lessee claims input tax on each payment.
- Instalment credit agreement (ICA): VAT is charged once, upfront, on the cash value of the goods. The lessee claims the full input tax at commencement, and the lessor recovers the VAT through the instalments.
The classification decides whether the IFRS 16 lease liability includes VAT. For a rental agreement it does not. For an ICA it does, which increases the liability by up to 15%.
| Rental agreement | Instalment credit agreement | |
|---|---|---|
| Time of supply | Each payment due or received (s 9(3)(a)) | Earlier of delivery and any payment (s 9(2)(b)) |
| Value of supply | Each rental | Cash value of the goods (s 10(6)) |
| Input tax claimed | On each payment | Once, at commencement |
| Payments used for the lease liability | VAT exclusive | VAT inclusive |
This article forms part of our guide to VAT in South Africa.
Rental Agreements
A rental agreement is any lease that is not an ICA. All property leases are rental agreements, as are short-term and operating-type rentals of equipment and vehicles.
Under section 9(3)(a), goods supplied under a rental agreement are treated as supplied successively, each time a payment falls due or is received, whichever is earlier. Each rental invoice carries VAT at 15%, and the lessor pays over output tax for each period.
The VAT on each payment is collected for SARS. It is not part of the amount the lessor finances, so the lessee's obligation to the lessor for the right to use the asset excludes it.
Exempt residential leases
The supply of accommodation in a dwelling under a lease is exempt under section 12(c). A residential lessor charges no VAT and cannot claim input tax on costs related to that supply. Commercial property leases are standard-rated.
Instalment Credit Agreements
An ICA is defined in section 1 of the VAT Act. It covers corporeal movable goods and machinery or plant (whether movable or immovable) supplied under either:
- an instalment sale agreement, where ownership passes to the buyer on or after payment; or
- a lease that meets the definition, broadly where the lessee bears the risk of loss or damage and the costs of insurance, maintenance and repair, and the total rentals exceed the cash value.
Typical examples are vehicle and equipment finance from banks and asset finance houses.
When and how VAT is charged
Under section 9(2)(b), the time of supply is the earlier of the delivery of the goods and any payment. The value of the supply is the cash value of the goods (section 10(6)), so VAT is charged on the price at which the goods would be sold for cash, not on the total instalments.
The finance charges are the provision of credit, which is an exempt financial service. No VAT is charged on them. This differs from a rental agreement, where VAT is charged on the full rental, including the lessor's return.
Who funds the VAT
The lessor accounts for the full output tax in the period of supply and pays it to SARS, but collects it from the lessee over the term of the agreement. The lessor is therefore financing the VAT, and earns finance income on it. The lessee claims the full input tax upfront, in the period of supply, while settling the VAT with the lessor over the term.
Effect on the Lease Liability
The lease liability is the present value of the payments the lessee owes the lessor for the right to use the asset.
- Rental agreement: the VAT on each payment is owed only because it is charged on that payment, and is recovered as input tax when paid. The liability is measured on VAT-exclusive payments. VAT is recognised as each payment is made.
- ICA: the VAT was charged at commencement and is now part of the amount owed to the lessor. The liability is measured on VAT-inclusive instalments.
Under an ICA, the input tax is calculated on the cash value, not on the lease liability or the total instalments. The right-of-use asset is the liability less the input tax claimed.
Practical Example
A manufacturer leases a packaging machine with a cash value of 1,000,000 (excluding VAT) for five years, with annual payments in arrears. The lessee is a registered vendor and uses the machine to make taxable supplies. The rate implicit in the lease is 11% and is readily determinable.
Structured as an ICA
The lessor charges output tax of 150,000 on delivery and finances 1,150,000 at 11%. The annual instalment is 311,156, with no further VAT charged on it.
| Commencement journal | Dr | Cr |
|---|---|---|
| Right-of-use asset | 1,000,000 | |
| VAT input | 150,000 | |
| Lease liability | 1,150,000 |
In year 1, interest is 1,150,000 × 11% = 126,500. The payment of 311,156 reduces the liability to 965,344. No VAT is recorded on the instalments.
Structured as a rental agreement
The lessor charges a rental of 270,570 plus VAT of 40,586 each year, a total of 311,156. The liability is the present value of the VAT-exclusive rentals at 11%:
- Lease liability and right-of-use asset: 270,570 × annuity factor (11%, 5) = 1,000,000
Each year's payment is recorded as:
| Year 1 payment | Dr | Cr |
|---|---|---|
| Lease liability (interest 110,000, capital 160,570) | 270,570 | |
| VAT input | 40,586 | |
| Bank | 311,156 |
Comparison
| ICA | Rental agreement | |
|---|---|---|
| Annual payment to lessor | 311,156 | 311,156 |
| Lease liability at commencement | 1,150,000 | 1,000,000 |
| Right-of-use asset | 1,000,000 | 1,000,000 |
| Input tax claimed | 150,000 at commencement | 40,586 each year (202,928 in total) |
| Total interest | 405,779 | 352,852 |
The payments were set equal to isolate the VAT effect. The right-of-use asset is the same, but under the ICA the liability, and the interest on it, includes the VAT the lessor financed.
When Input Tax Cannot Be Claimed
Where the lessee is not a vendor, uses the asset for exempt supplies, or is denied input tax, the VAT is a cost of the lease:
- Rental agreement: the VAT-inclusive payments are discounted into the lease liability.
- ICA: the VAT charged on the cash value is included in the right-of-use asset.
In the example, a lessee that cannot claim input tax recognises a lease liability and a right-of-use asset of 1,150,000 under either structure.
The most common case is a motor car. Section 17(2)(c) denies input tax on the acquisition of a motor car, including under a lease, so passenger vehicle leases are accounted for on a VAT-inclusive basis. See input tax denied.
Where the asset is used partly for taxable supplies, only the apportioned input tax is claimed, and the balance is included in the lease liability (rental agreement) or the right-of-use asset (ICA).
Lessor Accounting
- Rental agreement: the lessor accounts for output tax on each rental invoiced. Rental income, or finance income under a finance lease, is measured excluding VAT.
- ICA: the lessor accounts for output tax on the cash value in the period of supply. Under a finance lease, the net investment in the lease includes the VAT, which is recovered with finance income through the instalments.
An ICA is usually a finance lease under IFRS 16, because the lessee bears the risks of the asset, but the two classifications are separate tests.
Income Tax and Deferred Tax
The VAT classification also affects income tax. Under an instalment sale agreement, the lessee is treated as the owner and claims capital allowances and finance costs. Under a lease ICA or a rental agreement, the lessee deducts the lease payments under section 11(a). See tax on leases in South Africa.
For deferred tax, the VAT included in an ICA lease liability was claimed as input tax at commencement. It is not deductible again as the instalments are paid, so that portion of the liability is not deductible in future and is excluded from its tax base. Under a rental agreement, the liability excludes VAT, so no adjustment is needed. See deferred tax on leases.
Separating VAT from lease payments in Excel?
Leash automates lease schedules, journal entries, and IFRS 16 compliance, so you're not rebuilding this in Excel every month-end.
Conclusion
VAT on a lease follows its VAT Act classification. Under a rental agreement, VAT is charged and claimed on each payment, and the IFRS 16 lease liability is measured on VAT-exclusive payments. Under an instalment credit agreement, VAT is charged upfront on the cash value, claimed in full at commencement, and financed by the lessor, so the lease liability includes it. Where input tax cannot be claimed, the VAT is a cost of the lease under either structure.
For clarification, guidance, or feedback on our article, please reach out to us at insight@leash.co.za.
