Overview
A lease liability is remeasured when the lease payments change after the commencement date. The remeasured liability is the present value of the revised payments over the remaining lease term, and the change is generally recognised as an adjustment to the right-of-use asset.
Two things decide the accounting:
- Why the payments changed: a reassessment under the existing contract, or a modification of the contract.
- Which discount rate applies: the original rate, or a revised rate at the remeasurement date.
| Change | Type | Discount rate |
|---|---|---|
| Lease term (extension or termination option) | Reassessment | Revised |
| Purchase option assessment | Reassessment | Revised |
| Residual value guarantee: amount expected to be payable | Reassessment | Original |
| Index or rate (CPI, market rent review) | Reassessment | Original |
| Floating interest rate | Reassessment | Revised for the interest rate change |
| Agreed change in scope or consideration | Modification | Revised |
This article forms part of our full IFRS 16 guide.
Reassessment vs Modification
A reassessment (IFRS 16.39–43) reflects a change in facts or circumstances under the existing contract. Nothing is renegotiated. The lessee re-estimates the payments because an index has moved, an option has become reasonably certain, or the expected residual value has changed.
A lease modification (IFRS 16.44–46) is a change in the scope of the lease or the consideration that was not part of the original terms and conditions, such as a negotiated rent reduction, an extension outside the existing options, or the surrender of part of the premises. A modification is accounted for in one of three ways:
| Modification | Accounting |
|---|---|
| Adds a right to use another asset, at a price commensurate with its stand-alone price | Separate new lease; the original lease is unchanged (IFRS 16.44) |
| Decreases the scope (less space, shorter term) | Partial termination: reduce the right-of-use asset proportionately, gain or loss in profit or loss, then remeasure the remainder against the asset (IFRS 16.46(a)) |
| Any other change (rent change, extension, additional space not at stand-alone price) | Remeasure the liability at a revised rate against the right-of-use asset (IFRS 16.46(b)) |
The distinction matters because exercising an extension option that was in the original contract is a reassessment, while agreeing a new extension that was not is a modification. Both use a revised rate, but a modification also requires the consideration to be reallocated between lease and non-lease components. Decreases in scope are covered in lease terminations, and the modification types in lease modifications.
Which Discount Rate Applies
The logic behind IFRS 16.40–43 is that the discount rate is revised when the economics of the lease change, and kept when only the amount of an expected cash flow changes.
Revised rate (IFRS 16.40 and 45):
- a change in the lease term;
- a change in the assessment of an option to purchase the underlying asset; and
- a modification not accounted for as a separate lease.
The revised rate is the interest rate implicit in the lease for the remainder of the term if it can be readily determined, or the lessee's incremental borrowing rate at the reassessment or modification date, for the remaining term (IFRS 16.41).
Original rate (IFRS 16.42):
- a change in the amount expected to be payable under a residual value guarantee; and
- a change in future payments resulting from a change in an index or rate, including a market rent review. See lease escalations.
Where payments vary with a floating interest rate, the original rate is revised only to reflect the change in that interest rate (IFRS 16.43).
Market interest rates alone are not a trigger
A rise or fall in market interest rates does not require a remeasurement. A lessee only determines a new incremental borrowing rate when a remeasurement that calls for a revised rate is required for another reason.
Reassessing the Lease Term
A lessee reassesses whether it is reasonably certain to exercise an extension option, or not to exercise a termination option, only on a significant event or significant change in circumstances that is within its control and affects that assessment (IFRS 16.20). Examples in IFRS 16.B41 include:
- significant leasehold improvements not anticipated at commencement, that will still have significant value when the option becomes exercisable;
- a significant modification or customisation of the underlying asset;
- subleasing the asset beyond the end of the previously determined lease term; and
- a business decision directly relevant to the option, such as extending the lease of a complementary asset or disposing of an alternative one.
Market events, such as a fall in market rents, are not within the lessee's control and do not on their own trigger a reassessment.
The lease term is also revised when the non-cancellable period changes (IFRS 16.21), for example when the lessee exercises an option that was not included in the lease term, or does not exercise one that was.
Example 1: CPI Adjustment
A lessee leases offices for five years at 200,000 per year, payable in arrears. The payments are adjusted annually for CPI from year 2. The incremental borrowing rate at commencement is 8%.
- At commencement: future CPI increases are not forecast. Liability and right-of-use asset: 200,000 × annuity factor (8%, 5) = 798,542.
- End of year 1, after the payment: the liability is 662,425 and the right-of-use asset is 798,542 − 159,708 = 638,834.
CPI for year 1 is 6%, so the payments from year 2 increase to 212,000. The cash flows have changed, so the liability is remeasured at the original 8%:
- Remeasured liability: 212,000 × annuity factor (8%, 4) = 702,171
- Increase: 702,171 − 662,425 = 39,746
| Remeasurement journal | Dr | Cr |
|---|---|---|
| Right-of-use asset | 39,746 | |
| Lease liability | 39,746 |
Interest for year 2 is 702,171 × 8% = 56,174. The right-of-use asset of 678,580 is depreciated over the remaining four years at 169,645 per year.
The liability is remeasured when the adjusted payment takes effect, not when the index is published. If CPI is published in month 11 but only applies from month 13, the remeasurement is in month 13.
Example 2: Extension Option Becomes Reasonably Certain
A lessee leases a distribution centre for five years at 150,000 per year in arrears, at an incremental borrowing rate of 9%. The lease includes an option to extend for three years at 165,000 per year, which was not reasonably certain at commencement.
- At commencement: liability and right-of-use asset of 150,000 × annuity factor (9%, 5) = 583,448.
- End of year 3, after the payment: the liability is 263,867 and the right-of-use asset is 583,448 × 2/5 = 233,379.
During year 3 the lessee installs automated racking with a useful life of ten years. The investment is significant and within the lessee's control, so the extension option is now reasonably certain to be exercised. The lease term becomes five more years, and the liability is remeasured at a revised rate. The incremental borrowing rate for a five-year term is now 11%:
- Two remaining payments of 150,000: 256,879
- Three extension payments of 165,000, payable in years 3 to 5 from now: 327,256
- Remeasured liability: 584,135
- Increase: 584,135 − 263,867 = 320,268, debited to the right-of-use asset
The right-of-use asset of 553,648 is depreciated over the new remaining term of five years, at 110,730 per year. Using the original 9% would have given a liability of 615,406, which is 31,271 higher.
Example 3: Rent Reduction
Using the lease in Example 2 before the extension, the lessor instead agrees at the end of year 3 to reduce the rental to 130,000 for the remaining two years. Nothing else changes.
The change in consideration was not part of the original terms, so it is a modification. It does not decrease the scope of the lease, so it falls under IFRS 16.46(b): the liability is remeasured at a revised rate of 11% at the effective date, against the right-of-use asset.
- Remeasured liability: 130,000 × annuity factor (11%, 2) = 222,628
- Decrease: 263,867 − 222,628 = 41,239
| Modification journal | Dr | Cr |
|---|---|---|
| Lease liability | 41,239 | |
| Right-of-use asset | 41,239 |
No gain is recognised. The lower rent is spread over the remaining term through lower depreciation on the right-of-use asset of 192,140.
When the Right-of-Use Asset Reaches Zero
The right-of-use asset cannot be reduced below zero. Where a remeasurement reduces the liability by more than the carrying amount of the asset, the asset is reduced to zero and the remaining amount is recognised in profit or loss (IFRS 16.39).
This typically arises late in a lease, when the right-of-use asset has been mostly depreciated and a large reduction in payments or term is recognised.
After any remeasurement, the current and non-current split is taken from the revised schedule, and the deferred tax on the liability and the asset is recalculated.
Remeasuring lease liabilities in Excel?
Leash automates lease schedules, journal entries, and IFRS 16 compliance, so you're not rebuilding this in Excel every month-end.
Conclusion
A lease liability is remeasured whenever the lease payments change after commencement, either on a reassessment under the existing contract or on a modification. A change in the lease term, a purchase option assessment or a modification uses a revised discount rate; a change in an index, a rate or a residual value guarantee keeps the original one. The adjustment is recognised against the right-of-use asset, except for decreases in scope and amounts that would take the asset below zero, which are recognised in profit or loss.
For clarification, guidance, or feedback on our article, please reach out to us at insight@leash.co.za.
