Overview
Input tax is normally claimable on goods and services acquired for making taxable supplies. Section 17(2) of the VAT Act overrides this for three categories of expenditure that have a strong element of private consumption:
- Entertainment (s 17(2)(a))
- Club membership fees and subscriptions (s 17(2)(b))
- Motor cars (s 17(2)(c))
The denial applies even if the vendor makes only taxable supplies and the expense is entirely business-related.
Entertainment
Entertainment is defined as the provision of food, beverages, accommodation, entertainment, amusement, recreation or hospitality of any kind, whether directly or indirectly, to anyone. This covers client lunches, staff year-end functions, refreshments at meetings and corporate hospitality packages.
Input tax is still claimable where:
- the vendor supplies entertainment in the ordinary course of its business, such as a restaurant, hotel or caterer;
- the entertainment is supplied to customers or staff for a charge that covers its cost, such as a staff canteen run on a cost-recovery basis.
A narrower set of other exceptions in the provisos to section 17(2)(a) applies to specific industries.
Club Subscriptions
Membership fees and subscriptions to clubs for sport, social or recreation, such as golf and country clubs, are denied. Membership of professional bodies (for example SAICA or the Engineering Council) is not affected, and input tax remains claimable.
Motor Cars
A motor car includes a sedan, station wagon, minibus, double-cab bakkie and any other vehicle designed or adapted mainly for carrying passengers. Excluded from the definition are:
- vehicles that can carry more than 16 people;
- vehicles with an unladen mass of 3,500 kg or more;
- special-purpose vehicles such as ambulances, hearses and game-viewing vehicles;
- single-cab bakkies and panel vans, which are designed mainly for goods.
Input tax is not denied for motor car dealers, which hold the vehicles as trading stock, or for car rental businesses, which hire them out in the ordinary course of business.
Running costs are not denied
The denial applies to the acquisition (or rental) of the motor car. VAT on repairs, maintenance and insurance is claimable to the extent the vehicle is used for taxable supplies. Petrol and diesel are zero-rated, so there is no VAT to claim on fuel.
Consequences of Denial
- Cost: the VAT is included in the cost of the asset or expense, both in the financial statements and for income tax purposes.
- No output tax on sale: when the asset is later sold, the supply is not taxable (s 8(14)). A company that sells a sedan used by its sales staff charges no VAT on the sale.
- No change in use adjustments: because no input tax was claimed, no adjustment arises when the use of the asset changes.
Practical Example
A taxable vendor incurs the following costs in a VAT period:
| Expense (including VAT) | Amount | Input tax | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|
| Double-cab bakkie for a sales manager | 644,000 | - | Motor car, s 17(2)(c) |
| Panel van for deliveries | 402,500 | 52,500 | Not a motor car |
| Service of the bakkie | 9,200 | 1,200 | Running cost, not denied |
| Client golf day | 40,250 | - | Entertainment, s 17(2)(a) |
| Professional body membership | 6,900 | 900 | Not a club subscription |
The bakkie is recognised at 644,000, including VAT of 84,000, and depreciated on that amount. The golf day expense is 40,250. When the bakkie is sold, no output tax is charged.
Depreciating right-of-use vehicles in Excel?
Leash automates lease schedules, journal entries, and IFRS 16 and ASC 842 compliance, so you're not rebuilding this in Excel every month-end.
Conclusion
Section 17(2) treats entertainment, recreational club subscriptions and passenger vehicles as private consumption, regardless of the business purpose. The VAT forms part of cost, no output tax arises on a later sale, and the exceptions are limited to businesses that supply these items in the ordinary course, such as restaurants, hotels, car dealers and rental companies.
For how denied input tax fits into the wider VAT return, see our guide to VAT in South Africa. Vehicles leased rather than bought are covered in our article on the tax treatment of leases in South Africa, and the effect of denied input tax on the lease liability in VAT on leases.
For clarification, guidance, or feedback on our article, please reach out to us at insight@leash.co.za.
