Introduction
IFRS 16 and ASC 842 both require lessees to recognise almost all leases in the statement of financial position as a right-of-use asset and a lease liability. The fundamental difference lies in the income statement. IFRS 16 applies a single model, with depreciation and interest recognised separately for every lease. ASC 842 keeps a dual model: a lessee classifies each lease as a finance lease, accounted for in the same way as IFRS 16, or an operating lease, which produces a single straight-line lease cost.
The other differences are narrower but recur in practice: the low-value exemption, index-linked payments, discount rates, subleases, sale-and-leaseback gains and cash flow presentation.
IFRS 16 vs ASC 842 at a Glance
| Area | IFRS 16 | ASC 842 |
|---|---|---|
| Lessee model | Single model: depreciation and interest for every lease | Dual model: finance leases (depreciation and interest) or operating leases (single straight-line cost) |
| Low-value leases | Optional exemption, lease by lease | No exemption |
| Short-term leases | 12 months or less and no purchase option | 12 months or less and no purchase option reasonably certain of exercise |
| Classification thresholds | Judgement, no bright lines | 75% of economic life and 90% of fair value accepted as a reasonable approach |
| Discount rate | Implicit rate, else incremental borrowing rate | Same, plus a risk-free rate election for non-public entities |
| Index-linked payments | Liability remeasured when payments change | Not remeasured; changes recognised as variable lease cost |
| Restoration costs | Included in the right-of-use asset | Accounted for under ASC 410, outside the right-of-use asset |
| Shortening the lease term | Decrease in scope: proportionate derecognition, gain or loss | Not a decrease in scope: remeasure liability against the asset |
| Lessor finance leases | One category; manufacturer or dealer lessors recognise selling profit | Sales-type and direct financing leases |
| Subleases | Classified by reference to the head lease right-of-use asset | Classified by reference to the underlying asset |
| Sale-and-leaseback gain | Only the portion relating to rights transferred | Full gain, adjusted for off-market terms |
| Lessee interest paid | IAS 7 policy for interest paid | Operating (finance leases); whole payment operating (operating leases) |
Lessee Accounting: Single Model vs Dual Model
Under IFRS 16, the right-of-use asset is depreciated, usually on a straight-line basis, and interest accrues on the lease liability using the effective interest method. Because interest is highest while the liability is largest, total expense is front-loaded.
Under ASC 842, a lessee first classifies the lease. A finance lease is accounted for in the same way as IFRS 16. An operating lease produces a single lease cost, recognised on a straight-line basis. Interest on the liability is still calculated, and the right-of-use asset is reduced by the balancing figure, so that the two together equal the straight-line cost.
Practical Example
A lease runs for three years with payments of 100,000 annually in arrears and a discount rate of 8%. The lease liability and right-of-use asset at commencement are both 257,710.
| Year | Interest | IFRS 16 depreciation | IFRS 16 / ASC 842 finance: total expense | ASC 842 operating: lease cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 20,617 | 85,903 | 106,520 | 100,000 |
| 2 | 14,266 | 85,903 | 100,169 | 100,000 |
| 3 | 7,407 | 85,904 | 93,311 | 100,000 |
| Total | 42,290 | 257,710 | 300,000 | 300,000 |
Total expense is identical; only the timing differs. Under the ASC 842 operating lease the right-of-use asset is reduced by 79,383 in year one (100,000 less interest of 20,617), so at the end of year one it equals the lease liability of 178,327. Under IFRS 16 the asset is 171,807.
The effect on EBITDA
Depreciation and interest are both excluded from EBITDA, so IFRS 16 removes the cost of every recognised lease from EBITDA. The ASC 842 operating lease cost sits within operating expenses. The same lease portfolio reports a higher EBITDA under IFRS 16, which matters for covenants and comparisons between IFRS and US GAAP reporters. See finance vs operating leases under ASC 842.
Short-Term and Low-Value Leases
Both standards allow lessees to recognise short-term leases on a straight-line basis, by class of underlying asset. A short-term lease has a term of 12 months or less, but the definitions differ on purchase options:
- IFRS 16: a lease containing a purchase option is never a short-term lease.
- ASC 842: a lease is excluded only if the lessee is reasonably certain to exercise the option.
Only IFRS 16 offers a low-value exemption, applied lease by lease to assets with a low value when new, such as tablets, personal computers and office furniture. The IASB had in mind a guide of around USD 5,000. ASC 842 has no equivalent, and US entities rely on a capitalisation threshold and materiality instead.
Classification Criteria and Bright Lines
The five classification criteria are the same in both standards: transfer of ownership, a purchase option reasonably certain of exercise, a lease term for the major part of the economic life, a present value amounting to substantially all of the fair value, and a specialised asset. Under IFRS 16 they apply to lessors only; under ASC 842 they apply to lessees and lessors.
ASC 842 states that one reasonable approach is to treat 75% or more of the remaining economic life as a major part and 90% or more of fair value as substantially all. It also disregards the economic life criterion for a lease commencing in the final 25% of an asset's life. IFRS 16 sets no thresholds, and the indicators are applied with judgement. See finance lease vs operating lease under IFRS 16.
Discount Rates
Both standards use the rate implicit in the lease where it can be readily determined, and otherwise the lessee's incremental borrowing rate.
ASC 842 adds an election for entities other than public business entities to use a risk-free rate, by class of underlying asset. It simplifies measurement, but a risk-free rate is lower than a borrowing rate, so the lease liability and right-of-use asset are higher.
Index-Linked Payments and Remeasurement
Payments linked to an index such as CPI are measured using the index at commencement under both standards. The standards differ when the index moves:
- IFRS 16: the liability is remeasured when the payments change, using the unchanged discount rate, with the adjustment recognised against the right-of-use asset.
- ASC 842: the liability is not remeasured. The change in payments is recognised in profit or loss as variable lease cost when incurred. The current index is used only when the liability is remeasured for another reason, such as a modification or a change in the lease term.
A property portfolio with annual CPI escalations is therefore remeasured every year under IFRS 16 and rarely under ASC 842. See lease payment escalations under IFRS 16.
Right-of-Use Asset Measurement and Impairment
The cost of the right-of-use asset is built up in the same way, with one exception. Restoration and dismantling costs are included in the right-of-use asset under IFRS 16. Under ASC 842 they fall within ASC 410 as asset retirement obligations and are not part of the right-of-use asset.
Right-of-use assets are tested for impairment under IAS 36 for IFRS and under ASC 360 for US GAAP. After an impairment of an ASC 842 operating lease asset, the remaining asset is reduced on a straight-line basis, so the lease cost is no longer level for the rest of the term.
Modifications That Shorten the Lease Term
- IFRS 16: shortening the lease term is a decrease in scope. The lessee reduces the right-of-use asset in proportion to the reduction in the liability and recognises the difference as a gain or loss.
- ASC 842: shortening the term is not a partial termination. The liability is remeasured and the right-of-use asset adjusted by the same amount, with no gain or loss.
See lease modifications under IFRS 16 and lease terminations.
Lessor Accounting
Both standards classify lessor leases as finance or operating. ASC 842 divides the finance category in two:
- Sales-type lease: meets one of the five criteria. Selling profit or loss is recognised at commencement.
- Direct financing lease: meets none of the five criteria, but the present value of the lease payments plus any third-party residual value guarantee amounts to substantially all of the fair value and collection is probable. Selling profit is deferred into the net investment; a selling loss is recognised at commencement.
IFRS 16 has one finance lease category. A manufacturer or dealer lessor recognises selling profit at commencement, an outcome similar to a sales-type lease, and expenses its initial direct costs. Other finance lessors include initial direct costs in the net investment.
ASC 842 also applies a collectibility test that IFRS 16 does not. Where collection of a sales-type lease is not probable, the lessor keeps the asset and records payments received as a deposit liability.
Subleases
- IFRS 16: an intermediate lessor classifies the sublease by reference to the right-of-use asset arising from the head lease. A sublease for most of the remaining head lease term is often a finance lease.
- ASC 842: the sublease is classified by reference to the underlying asset, so most subleases under ASC 842 are operating leases.
Sale-and-Leaseback Transactions
Both standards first ask whether the transfer is a sale under the revenue standard. A repurchase option held by the seller-lessee generally prevents sale accounting under IFRS 15. ASC 842 permits sale accounting with a repurchase option only where the exercise price is fair value at exercise and alternative assets are readily available.
Where a sale has occurred:
- IFRS 16: the seller-lessee measures the right-of-use asset at the proportion of the previous carrying amount retained and recognises only the gain relating to the rights transferred.
- ASC 842: the leaseback is accounted for like any other lease and the full gain is recognised, adjusted for off-market terms.
Cash Flow Presentation
| Payment | IFRS 16 | ASC 842 |
|---|---|---|
| Principal | Financing | Financing (finance leases); the whole payment is operating (operating leases) |
| Interest | IAS 7 policy for interest paid | Operating |
| Short-term, low-value and variable payments | Operating | Operating |
IFRS 16 reporters therefore show higher operating cash flows for the same leases. From 2027, IFRS 18 requires entities without a specified main business activity to classify interest paid as financing. See lease payments in the cash flow statement.
Scope and Non-Lease Components
ASC 842 excludes leases of intangible assets, biological assets including timber, inventory, assets under construction, and rights to explore for or use minerals, oil and natural gas.
IFRS 16 excludes leases to explore for or use minerals, oil and natural gas, biological assets within IAS 41 held by a lessee, service concession arrangements, licences of intellectual property granted by a lessor, and rights held by a lessee under licensing agreements within IAS 38. A lessee may also choose to apply IFRS 16 to other leases of intangible assets.
Both standards allow a lessee to elect, by class of underlying asset, not to separate non-lease components. ASC 842 also offers lessors a similar expedient where the timing and pattern of transfer are the same and the lease component would be an operating lease. IFRS 16 lessors must separate.
Disclosure
Both standards require a maturity analysis of lease liabilities and disclosure of lease cost by type. ASC 842 additionally requires the weighted-average remaining lease term and weighted-average discount rate, separately for operating and finance leases, and a reconciliation of the undiscounted maturity analysis to the lease liability. IFRS 16 places more weight on qualitative information about the lessee's leasing activities. See IFRS 16 disclosures.
Reporting under both IFRS 16 and ASC 842?
Leash automates lease schedules, journal entries, and compliance for both IFRS 16 and ASC 842, so you're not rebuilding this in Excel every month-end.
Conclusion
IFRS 16 and ASC 842 agree that almost every lease belongs on the balance sheet. They differ in how the cost reaches the income statement: one model under IFRS 16, two under ASC 842. The narrower differences, from the low-value exemption and CPI remeasurement to subleases and sale-and-leaseback gains, produce different numbers from the same contract, so entities reporting under both frameworks need to track each lease twice.
For more on each framework, see our full IFRS 16 guide.
For clarification, guidance, or feedback on our article, please reach out to us at insight@leash.co.za.
