The Difference
Zero-rated and exempt supplies both result in no VAT on the customer's invoice, but they are treated in opposite ways for the supplier.
| Zero-rated (s 11) | Exempt (s 12) | |
|---|---|---|
| Taxable supply? | Yes | No |
| Output tax | 0% | None |
| Input tax on related costs | Claimable | Not claimable |
| Counts towards registration threshold | Yes | No |
The VAT on a zero-rated supplier's costs is recovered from SARS. The VAT on an exempt supplier's costs is not, so it becomes part of the supplier's cost base and is usually passed on in its prices.
Zero-Rated Supplies
Zero-rating removes VAT from supplies that are either consumed outside South Africa or that government has chosen to relieve. The main categories are:
- Exported goods delivered by the vendor to an address outside South Africa, supported by documentary proof.
- International transport of goods and passengers, and related insurance.
- Services to non-residents, other than services relating to South African land or movable property, or rendered while the non-resident is in South Africa.
- Basic foodstuffs listed in Schedule 2, petrol and diesel subject to the fuel levy, illuminating paraffin and sanitary products.
- Municipal property rates.
- A business sold as a going concern between two vendors (see sale of a going concern).
Proof is a condition
An export is zero-rated only if the vendor holds the required export documents. If they are not obtained within the prescribed period, the vendor must account for output tax at 15%, even though the price charged excluded VAT.
Exempt Supplies
Exemption applies mainly where VAT would be difficult to measure (financial margins) or where the supply is a basic need (housing, public transport, education).
- Financial services: interest, the provision of credit, issuing and transferring shares and debt securities, long-term insurance and cryptocurrency. Fees and commissions are not exempt.
- Residential accommodation in a dwelling. Hotels, guesthouses and similar commercial accommodation are standard-rated.
- Local passenger transport by road or rail. Domestic flights are standard-rated.
- Qualifying educational services, childcare by crèches and after-school centres, and trade union membership contributions.
Practical Example
Two businesses each incur maintenance, security and management costs of 230,000, including VAT of 30,000.
- An exporter sells all of its goods abroad at the zero rate. It claims the 30,000 as input tax and, with no output tax to offset, receives a refund of 30,000. Its cost is 200,000.
- A residential landlord lets unfurnished flats, an exempt supply. It cannot claim the 30,000, so its cost is the full 230,000.
Neither charges VAT to its customers, yet the landlord's costs are 15% higher. Zero-rating relieves the full chain from VAT; exemption only relieves the final step.
Mixed Suppliers
Many vendors make both taxable and exempt supplies: a property group letting offices (standard-rated) and flats (exempt), or a lender charging interest (exempt) and fees (standard-rated).
- Input tax on costs used only for taxable supplies is claimed in full.
- Input tax on costs used only for exempt supplies is not claimed.
- Input tax on shared costs is apportioned, by default on the turnover-based method: taxable supplies (standard-rated and zero-rated) divided by total supplies, all excluding VAT. If the result is 95% or more, the full amount is claimed.
A change in the mix of supplies can also require change in use adjustments on assets, covered in our guide to VAT in South Africa.
Mixed suppliers are also liable for VAT on imported services to the extent of their exempt use, under the reverse charge.
Building lease schedules in Excel?
Leash automates lease schedules, journal entries, and IFRS 16 and ASC 842 compliance, so you're not rebuilding this in Excel every month-end.
Conclusion
The rate on the invoice is the same, but the classification decides whether VAT on costs is recovered. Zero-rated supplies are taxable and carry full input tax; exempt supplies are not and carry none. For businesses that make both, the turnover-based apportionment determines how much of the VAT on shared costs is recovered.
For clarification, guidance, or feedback on our article, please reach out to us at insight@leash.co.za.
