VAT or Transfer Duty?
A transfer of fixed property in South Africa attracts either VAT or transfer duty, never both. The deciding question is whether the seller charges VAT:
| Seller | Tax on the sale | Buyer's VAT claim |
|---|---|---|
| Vendor, selling in the course of its enterprise | VAT at 15% (or 0% for a going concern). No transfer duty. | Actual input tax, with a tax invoice |
| Non-vendor, or a vendor selling a private asset | Transfer duty, paid by the buyer | Notional input tax, if the buyer is a vendor |
Fixed property includes land, buildings, sectional title units, and real rights in land such as a usufruct or servitude. Property sold as part of a business follows the rules for the sale of a going concern.
Seller Charges VAT
A developer selling new units, or a property company selling a building it has let commercially, charges VAT. The time of supply is the earlier of registration of transfer or any payment, but the seller accounts for output tax only to the extent payment has been received. The buyer, if a vendor, claims input tax on the same basis, to the extent of its taxable use.
The extent-of-payment rule does not apply between connected persons, where the value is the open market value. Where the price is paid in full on transfer, as is usual with bond finance, the full VAT is accounted for in that period.
Check the price clause
A price agreed between a vendor seller and a buyer is deemed to include VAT unless the agreement states otherwise. An agreement for 2,300,000 "including VAT" yields 2,000,000 for the seller after 300,000 of output tax.
Seller Is Not a Vendor: Notional Input Tax
If the seller is an individual or another non-vendor, no VAT is charged and the buyer pays transfer duty. A vendor buyer may still claim notional input tax on second-hand goods, which include fixed property:
Notional input tax = 15/115 × lower of (consideration and open market value)
- The consideration includes the transfer duty paid.
- The claim is limited to the extent of payment made.
- It may only be claimed once the property is registered in the buyer's name in the deeds registry.
- It is apportioned for the buyer's taxable use. Residential letting is exempt, so a buy-to-let flat generates no claim.
Practical Example
A manufacturing company (a vendor) buys a factory building from a retired individual for 4,000,000 and pays transfer duty of 280,000 (an assumed amount for illustration). The open market value is 4,500,000. The building will be used wholly for manufacturing, a taxable activity. The price is paid in full on registration of transfer.
| Calculation | Amount |
|---|---|
| Purchase price | 4,000,000 |
| Transfer duty | 280,000 |
| Consideration | 4,280,000 |
| Lower of consideration and open market value (4,500,000) | 4,280,000 |
| Notional input tax (4,280,000 × 15/115) | 558,261 |
The notional input tax is claimed in the VAT period in which transfer is registered. Had the building been used 70% for taxable supplies, the claim would be 390,783 (558,261 × 70%).
Cost for Income Tax
Input tax claimed, actual or notional, is excluded from cost for income tax purposes (s 23C). Using the example above:
| Cost for capital allowances and base cost | Amount |
|---|---|
| Purchase price | 4,000,000 |
| Add: transfer duty | 280,000 |
| Less: notional input tax claimed | (558,261) |
| Cost | 3,721,739 |
The same amount is the cost of the building under IAS 16, which includes transfer duty and excludes recoverable taxes. Any later difference between tax allowances and depreciation gives rise to deferred tax.
Building property lease schedules in Excel?
Leash automates lease schedules, journal entries, and IFRS 16 and ASC 842 compliance, so you're not rebuilding this in Excel every month-end.
Conclusion
Property transfers carry either VAT or transfer duty, depending on whether the seller charges VAT. A vendor buyer recovers the tax either way: actual input tax when VAT is charged, or notional input tax on the price plus transfer duty when it is not. In both cases the claim is limited to the extent of payment and of taxable use.
For the wider VAT framework, see our guide to VAT in South Africa.
For clarification, guidance, or feedback on our article, please reach out to us at insight@leash.co.za.
